- Ready Made Graham Cracker Crust (either graham crust OR chocolate crust you can use).... try using a deep dish style pie crust like a 9 inch if you can get one.....Or you can make your own crust • - Cups Cold Milk • -Packages Jello Instant pudding and Pie, Chocolate Flavor (4 ounce size) • -Tub Cool Whip Frozen Topping (thawed) 8 ounce size • Vanilla Extract • -Pack Marshmallows (either small size OR Large size) • Broken up pieces of Oreo Chocolate cookies