Sugar Cream Pie
This is the Indiana state pie, if there is such a thing LOL! It's popular where I'm from and insanely easy to make. Total time includes baking two pie shells first, preping while baking pie shells, and then basically cooking ingedients and pouring into pie shells.
The picture shows 4 pies. I just doubled the recipe.
Also, I typically use around 1/2 the sugar the recipe calls for.
Enjoy!
Sugar Cream Pie
This is the Indiana state pie, if there is such a thing LOL! It's popular where I'm from and insanely easy to make. Total time includes baking two pie shells first, preping while baking pie shells, and then basically cooking ingedients and pouring into pie shells.
The picture shows 4 pies. I just doubled the recipe.
Also, I typically use around 1/2 the sugar the recipe calls for.
Enjoy!
Cooking Instructions
- 1
Bake the two pie shells first and set aside to cool. After ingredients below are cooked they are then poured into the two pie shells and left to cool and then placed in the refrigerator to solidify.
- 2
I pre mix the wet ingredients by melting the margarine and then adding all other wet ingredients. Dry ingredients I mix in a separate bowl.
- 3
From there, heat 1/2 of the pre mixed wet ingredients over medium heat until close to boil.
- 4
Next add all dry ingredients and stir until it becomes thick and all lumps are out.
- 5
Now turn up the heat close to high and and the remaining 1/2 of the wet ingredients. Bring to a boil and then turn the heat off and constantly stir until thick. If it's slightly runny that's ok as it should solidify after it sets.
- 6
Pour into the pie crusts and sprinkle on nutmeg after pouring. Leave set for a bit and then refrigerate to solidify. I usually refrigerate overnight.
Cooksnaps
Did you make this recipe? Share a picture of your creation!
Similar Recipes
-
-
Chocolate Cream Pie Chocolate Cream Pie
This and coconut are my favorite pies. This recipe is for regular pie shell. Can double if using deep dish pie crust.
-
Chocolate Cream Pie Chocolate Cream Pie
A super yummy chocolate cream pie recipe. I used shredded semi-sweet chocolate for garnish instead of sprinkles and a few chips too. Looked and tasted great! ~(o.o)~
-
-
-
My Chocolate Cream Pie My Chocolate Cream Pie
Rich and Decadent. My Chocolate Cream pie is what dreams are made of. My homemade chocolate pudding is topped with whipped cream and chocolate shavings poured on top of my delicious pie crust.
-
Banana Cream Pie Banana Cream Pie
May 1st, 2017...Project Forward cooking elective....for our last class of the semester , this is one of the student's favorite pie. This recipe makes individual pies in a muffin tin.
-
Coconut Cream Pie Coconut Cream Pie
When I first learned how to make meringue, this became my trademark pie.
-
Coconut Cream Pie Coconut Cream Pie
#may2026 This is my moms recipe. My I miss her. I find a lot of treasures in her recipe box. This one is a favorite and deserves a spot on my 2026 calendar.
-
More Recipes
Comments