CookpadCookpad
Guest
Register or Log In
Save and create recipes, send cooksnaps and more
  • Search
  • Premium
    • Top Cooksnapped Recipes
    • Top Viewed Recipes
  • Premium
  • Challenges
  • FAQ
  • Send Feedback
  • Region
  • Your Collection
Your Collection
To start creating your recipe library, please register or login.
Amish bakery custard pie
Save this recipe to come back to it later.
  • Add Cooksnap
  • Add to folders
  • Print
  • Share
    • Copied!
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Pin it
    • Twitter
  • Report Recipe
  • See report
  • Edit recipe
  • Delete
CookpadCookpad
A picture of Amish bakery custard pie.

Amish bakery custard pie

His girl skye
His girl skye @cook_2829098

this easy to make pie is so creamy and simply delicious. it has become a favorite around our home... *nods nods*

this easy to make pie is so creamy and simply delicious. it has become a favorite around our home... *nods nods*

Read more

Amish bakery custard pie

His girl skye
His girl skye @cook_2829098

this easy to make pie is so creamy and simply delicious. it has become a favorite around our home... *nods nods*

this easy to make pie is so creamy and simply delicious. it has become a favorite around our home... *nods nods*

Read more
Saved
Save this recipe to come back to it later.
Edit recipe
See report
Add to folders
Add CooksnapAdd Cooksnap
ShareShare
  • Copied!
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Pin it
  • Twitter
PrintPrint
  • PrintPrint
  • Add CooksnapAdd Cooksnap
  • Report Recipe
  • See report
  • Delete
Share
  • Copied!
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Pin it
  • Twitter
Save this recipe to come back to it later.
  • Add Cooksnap
  • Add to folders
  • Print
  • Report Recipe
  • See report
  • Edit recipe
  • Delete

Ingredients

  • 1(9 in) baked pie crust *(see my recipes for a quick no-roll pie crust)
  • 3/4 cupsugar
  • 1/4 cupcornstarch
  • 1/4 tspsalt
  • 2 1/2 cuphalf-and-half
  • 1/2 cup(1 stick) butter
  • 1/4 cuppacked light brown sugar
  • 1 tspvanilla extract
  • 1ground cinnamon for sprinkling on top
Cookpad Open in Cookpad App
Saved
Save this recipe to come back to it later.

Steps

  1. 1

    preheat oven to 325°F

  2. 2

    in a medium saucepan, combine sugar, cornstarch and salt. whisk in the half-and-half and then cook over medium heat until mixture is thickened and bubbly. .. remembering to stir frequently so that it doesn't stick or scorch.

  3. 3

    remove from heat, add butter, brown sugar and vanilla and stir til butter is melted. pour into baked pie shell and sprinkle with cinnamon. (I usually have a little custard left over... ao I put it in oven safe custard cups and bake it alongside the pie)

    A picture of step 3 of Amish bakery custard pie.
  4. 4

    bake 35 minutes. CENTER OF PIE WILL NOT BE SET! this is important. the center will still be loose. cool pie 1 hour, then refrigerate 6 - 8 hours. pie will set upon chilling. do not skimp on the refrigerator time.

  5. 5

    slice... plate... enjoy!

  6. 6

    just to let everyone know. .. this is not my recipe. I found it on the Mr Food test kitchen website.

Saved
Save this recipe to come back to it later.
Edit recipe
See report
Add to folders
Add CooksnapAdd Cooksnap
ShareShare
  • Copied!
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Pin it
  • Twitter
PrintPrint
  • PrintPrint
  • Add CooksnapAdd Cooksnap
  • Report Recipe
  • See report
  • Delete

Cooksnaps

Saved
Save this recipe to come back to it later.
  • Add Cooksnap
  • Add to folders
  • Print
  • Share
    • Copied!
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Pin it
    • Twitter
  • Report Recipe
  • See report
  • Edit recipe
  • Delete

Copied!

His girl skye
His girl skye @cook_2829098
on November 11, 2013 16:54
well hi there! I'm skye. I love food and I love to eat. so I guess it's a good thing that I also love to cook...::smiles::
Read more

Comments (12)

Mimi
Mimi @Mimi2008
November 23, 2023 22:15
When u make this do you bake ur pie crust first or pour the mixture into it raw?
Guest
Add a comment
0/0

Top Search in

  1. 1st for custard

Keywords

Pie Custard Butter

Similar Recipes

More Recipes

  1. A picture of Power of Grains~Vegan Wok Fried Rice😋.

    Power of Grains~Vegan Wok Fried Rice😋

    Anoli Vinchhi Anoli Vinchhi
  2. A picture of Chorley Cake - Lancashire Cake to Use Up Spare Pastry - So Nearly FREE :P Enjoy :P.

    Chorley Cake - Lancashire Cake to Use Up Spare Pastry - So Nearly FREE :P Enjoy :P

    farang31 farang31
  3. A picture of Andy Aloo Gravy 🥔🥔🥚🥚.

    Andy Aloo Gravy 🥔🥔🥚🥚

    Kulsoom Bukhari Kulsoom Bukhari
  4. A picture of Summer Special Juicy Jowar & Tofu Colorful Salad Bowl.

    Summer Special Juicy Jowar & Tofu Colorful Salad Bowl

    Krishna Dholakia Krishna Dholakia
  5. A picture of Amaranth Puri.

    Amaranth Puri

    Yadnya Desai Yadnya Desai
  6. A picture of Popped Jowar Upma.

    Popped Jowar Upma

    Suchitra S(Radhika S) Suchitra S(Radhika S)
  7. A picture of Jowar and Lauki Noodles.

    Jowar and Lauki Noodles

    Shilpa Shah Shilpa Shah
  8. A picture of Brad's Swedish Meatballs.

    Brad's Swedish Meatballs

    wingmaster835 wingmaster835
  9. A picture of Chocolate Zucchini Loaf Cake.

    Chocolate Zucchini Loaf Cake

    Becca N. Becca N.
  10. A picture of Foxtail Millet Khichdi.

    Foxtail Millet Khichdi

    Bethica Das Bethica Das
  11. A picture of Grasshopper Pie.

    Grasshopper Pie

    fenway fenway
  12. A picture of no roll pie crust.

    no roll pie crust

    His girl skye His girl skye
  13. A picture of Rice and bean casserole with turkey.

    Rice and bean casserole with turkey

    Taylor Topp Comacho Taylor Topp Comacho
  14. A picture of Cocoa almonds.

    Cocoa almonds

    Taylor Topp Comacho Taylor Topp Comacho
  15. A picture of Broccoli and Spinach White Lasagna.

    Broccoli and Spinach White Lasagna

    Ms.China Ms.China
  16. A picture of Andrea's BBQ Chicken Nachos.

    Andrea's BBQ Chicken Nachos

    amichaud1 amichaud1
  17. A picture of Spaghetti With Leeks.

    Spaghetti With Leeks

    Lyii G Lyii G
  18. A picture of Chicken and Waffle Bacon Turkey Sandwhich.

    Chicken and Waffle Bacon Turkey Sandwhich

    trey.paradis trey.paradis
  19. A picture of cranberrie baked chicken.

    cranberrie baked chicken

    Brenda M. Castillo Brenda M. Castillo
  20. A picture of no roll pie crust.

    no roll pie crust

    His girl skye His girl skye
  21. A picture of Broccoli and Spinach White Lasagna.

    Broccoli and Spinach White Lasagna

    Ms.China Ms.China
  22. A picture of cheese stuffed manicotti.

    cheese stuffed manicotti

    beccaspezz beccaspezz
  23. A picture of Taly's Special Mix Sandwishes.

    Taly's Special Mix Sandwishes

    MatrixNSS MatrixNSS
  24. A picture of Chicken Sous Vide.

    Chicken Sous Vide

    MatrixNSS MatrixNSS
  25. A picture of Strawberry Mousse.

    Strawberry Mousse

    cookpad.japan cookpad.japan
https://cookpad.wasmer.app/us/recipes/366337
Cookpad Open in Cookpad App

About Us

Our mission at Cookpad is to make everyday cooking fun, because we believe that cooking is key to a happier and healthier life for people, communities and the planet. We empower home cooks all over the world to help each other by sharing their recipes and cooking experiences.

Subscribe to Premium for exclusive features & benefits!

Cookpad Communities

🇺🇸 United States 🇬🇧 United Kingdom 🇪🇸 España 🇦🇷 Argentina 🇺🇾 Uruguay 🇲🇽 México 🇨🇱 Chile 🇻🇳 Việt Nam 🇹🇭 ไทย 🇮🇩 Indonesia 🇫🇷 France 🇸🇦 السعودية 🇹🇼 臺灣 🇮🇹 Italia 🇮🇷 ایران 🇮🇳 India 🇭🇺 Magyarország 🇳🇬 Nigeria 🇬🇷 Ελλάδα 🇲🇾 Malaysia 🇵🇹 Portugal 🇺🇦 Україна 🇯🇵 日本 See All

Learn More

Cookpad Premium Careers Feedback Blog Terms of Service Community Guidelines Privacy Policy Frequently Asked Questions

Download our app

Open Cookpad App on Google Play Open Cookpad App on App Store
Copyright © Cookpad Inc. All Rights Reserved
close