Jo's Chicken Pot Pie Filling

Johanna Crystal
Johanna Crystal @hanacrys

A hearty, homemade savory pie filling that utilizes herbs and lactose-free ingredients. It is an easy-to-make classic! And you can substitute speciality items for what you already have at home.

To pair with my plant-based pie crust, check out the recipe here: https://bit.ly/39wQdNs

Jo's Chicken Pot Pie Filling

A hearty, homemade savory pie filling that utilizes herbs and lactose-free ingredients. It is an easy-to-make classic! And you can substitute speciality items for what you already have at home.

To pair with my plant-based pie crust, check out the recipe here: https://bit.ly/39wQdNs

Edit recipe
See report
Share
Share

Ingredients

1 hour
6 servings
  1. Filling
  2. 5fresh garlic cloves, peeled and crushed*
  3. 1medium red onion, peeled and chopped
  4. 1 stickEarth Balance dairy-free butter*, halved
  5. 2 tablespoonsolive oil
  6. 4 cupscooked chicken, shredded and seasoned
  7. 4-5fresh carrots, peeled and sliced
  8. 1 cupfrozen peas
  9. 2 cupschicken stock
  10. 1 teaspoonlemon juice
  11. 1 cuplactose-free half and half*
  12. 1/4 cuptapioca flour*
  13. 3/4 teaspoonblack pepper
  14. 1/2 teaspoonsea salt, more or less to taste*
  15. 1 teaspoondried parsley
  16. 1/2 teaspooncelery seed
  17. 2-3 dashesdried oregano
  18. 1generous pinch smoked paprika
  19. 1-2 dashesVietnamese cinnamon
  20. 6large fresh basil leaves, chopped
  21. 1deep dish 9" pie pan or skillet, buttered/floured or oiled
  22. Prepared dough for 2 9" pie crusts
  23. room temp water or egg-wash (whisked egg + milk) for brushing
  24. Substitution Notes
  25. 3 tbscornstarch can be subbed for tapioca flour
  26. 1 1/4 tbsgarlic granules can be subbed for garlic cloves
  27. traditional salted butter can be subbed for dairy-free butter
  28. amount of carrots depends on size; organic tends to be slimmer
  29. amount of salt depends on if butter and stock is unsalted
  30. reg half/half is ok, but gut will probably prefer lactose-free
  31. precooked seasoned breast meat or rotisserie chicken is ideal

Cooking Instructions

1 hour
  1. 1

    Preheat oven to 400 degrees fahrenheit. If your oven runs extra hot and has a tendency to obliterate your food, try 375.

  2. 2

    Prep your ingredients - peel and chop your onion and crush your garlic, set aside. Rinse, peel and slice carrots into thin coins. Measure out peas and let them sit at room temperature. Roughly chop basil and set aside separately.

  3. 3

    Lightly rinse a large saucepan and shake out excess water into the sink. Set it on low-medium heat on the stove. Once water droplets have evaporated, melt 1/2 stick of butter plus 1 tbs olive oil in pan. Let it heat thoroughly for a couple of minutes. Stir or swirl the pan for even heat distribution and to prevent premature browning or burning. Adjust heat as needed.

  4. 4

    Add onions and garlic into the pan, and sautee for a few minutes until onions are translucent and garlic is lightly browned. Add in remaining butter and oil, and heat through.

  5. 5

    Once additional butter has melted, stir in carrots and peas into the pan. Once carrots are cooked but still slightly firm, add lemon juice, chicken stock, and basil. Stir occasionally.

  6. 6

    In a separate container, mix half and half and tapioca flour together. Whisk until blended and smooth. Gently pour into pan and stir.

  7. 7

    Continue to stir and let the mixture thicken for a minute or two, then add in the pre-cooked shredded chicken. Add in herbs and spices. Taste and add desired amount of salt. Stir to combine. Turn heat down to a simmer and stir frequently as the mixture comes together and is heated through. Do not boil.

  8. 8

    Remove the pan from heat. Gently pour mixture into prepared crust pan. (pictured: my plant-based pie crust)

  9. 9

    Carefully take premade top crust and cover the filling. Using your index fingers and thumbs, firmly pinch the edges to seal the top of the pie. You can trim excess dough with food-safe scissors. Take a fork or butter knife and gingerly make 3 small slits starting at the center of the pie and outward to create ventilation. Evenly brush the top and edges with prepared egg-wash or water.

  10. 10

    Cover the edges of the pie crust with foil to prevent premature browning. Place pie in heated oven on the center rack, and place a foiled cookie sheet on the rack below to catch any drips. Let bake for 35-40 minutes.

  11. 11

    Check on pie. If top is still heavily doughy, add time in 5 minute increments until top is golden brown. If filling bubbles up, it's okay! And if the top of the pie crust is mostly golden brown but has some slightly softer spots it's okay; it will keep cooking outside of the oven. Remove from oven with mitts and let it sit on top of the stove for 10 minutes. Place on cooling rack for at least 25 min before serving to let it set. Caution: it will be hot. As pies directly from the oven tend to be.

  12. 12

    Cut desired portions and transfer to plates. Serve it with joy and pride.

Edit recipe
See report
Share

Cooksnaps

Did you make this recipe? Share a picture of your creation!

Grey hand-drawn cartoon of a camera and a frying pan with stars rising from the pan
Cook Today
Johanna Crystal
Johanna Crystal @hanacrys
on

Comments

Fresh-Feast
Fresh-Feast @cook_27679748
That looks incredible, the filling looks so moorish!

Similar Recipes