CookpadCookpad
Guest
Register or Log In
Save and create recipes, send cooksnaps and more
  • Search
  • Premium
    • Top Cooksnapped Recipes
    • Top Viewed Recipes
  • Premium
  • Challenges
  • FAQ
  • Send Feedback
  • Region
  • Your Collection
Your Collection
To start creating your recipe library, please register or login.
Nutter Butter Sandwich Cookies
Save this recipe to come back to it later.
  • Add Cooksnap
  • Add to folders
  • Print
  • Share
    • Copied!
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Pin it
    • Twitter
  • Report Recipe
  • See report
  • Edit recipe
  • Delete
CookpadCookpad
A picture of Nutter Butter Sandwich Cookies.

Nutter Butter Sandwich Cookies

Kamado John Wayne
Kamado John Wayne @cook_3447445
East Berlin, Pennsylvania

Delicious copycat recipe. If you like peanut butter, you'll love these! I fiddled with a recipe making the rounds on social media and am very pleased with the end result.

Delicious copycat recipe. If you like peanut butter, you'll love these! I fiddled with a recipe making the rounds on social media and am very pleased with the end result.

Read more

Nutter Butter Sandwich Cookies

Kamado John Wayne
Kamado John Wayne @cook_3447445
East Berlin, Pennsylvania

Delicious copycat recipe. If you like peanut butter, you'll love these! I fiddled with a recipe making the rounds on social media and am very pleased with the end result.

Delicious copycat recipe. If you like peanut butter, you'll love these! I fiddled with a recipe making the rounds on social media and am very pleased with the end result.

Read more
Saved
Save this recipe to come back to it later.
Edit recipe
See report
Add to folders
Add CooksnapAdd Cooksnap
ShareShare
  • Copied!
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Pin it
  • Twitter
PrintPrint
  • PrintPrint
  • Add CooksnapAdd Cooksnap
  • Report Recipe
  • See report
  • Delete
Share
  • Copied!
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Pin it
  • Twitter
Save this recipe to come back to it later.
  • Add Cooksnap
  • Add to folders
  • Print
  • Report Recipe
  • See report
  • Edit recipe
  • Delete

Ingredients

20 Minutes
12-16 servings
  • Cookies:
  • 1 CupPeanut Butter
  • 1 CupSugar
  • 1Large Egg
  • Sandwich Cream Filling:
  • 1 CupConfectioners (Powdered) Sugar
  • 1/4 CupPeanut Butter @ Room Temperature
  • 1/4 CupButter @ Room Temperature
  • SplashWhole Milk
Cookpad Open in Cookpad App
Saved
Save this recipe to come back to it later.

Steps

20 Minutes
  1. 1

    Preheat the oven to 350°

  2. 2

    Cookies Directions: Mix the COOKIE ingredients together until smooth in a mixing bowl.

  3. 3

    Spoon small amounts of dough out of bowl and roll into balls approximately 3/4 inch round. Place balls on parchment paper on cookie sheet. Use a fork to press down balls flat, turn fork 90° and press again to make a criss-crossed pattern.

  4. 4

    Bake cookies for 12 -14 minutes until golden brown and semi-firm.

  5. 5

    Sandwich Cream Filling Directions: In a large mixing bowl, beat butter and peanut butter until smooth.

  6. 6

    Slowly add confectioners sugar to mixture, continue beating until smooth.

  7. 7

    Add small splashes of milk, while beating mixture until reaches desired consistency. (Usually about 1-2 Tablespoons is all it'll take). I like it fluffy and sticky.

  8. 8

    Spread Sandwich Cream Filling on cookies and make sandwiches.

Saved
Save this recipe to come back to it later.
Edit recipe
See report
Add to folders
Add CooksnapAdd Cooksnap
ShareShare
  • Copied!
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Pin it
  • Twitter
PrintPrint
  • PrintPrint
  • Add CooksnapAdd Cooksnap
  • Report Recipe
  • See report
  • Delete

Cooksnaps

Saved
Save this recipe to come back to it later.
  • Add Cooksnap
  • Add to folders
  • Print
  • Share
    • Copied!
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Pin it
    • Twitter
  • Report Recipe
  • See report
  • Edit recipe
  • Delete

Copied!

Kamado John Wayne
Kamado John Wayne @cook_3447445
on September 03, 2018 00:42
East Berlin, Pennsylvania
I love to cook. BBQ, Sous Vide, Mexican, Italian, American Breakfast, Strange-Fusion... I just love cooking, creating and eating food.I do about 80% of my cooking on a Kamado Joe Classic II Ceramic Smoker/Grill.I pride myself on developing recipes that are easy and delicious.In addition to cooking, I love the Philadelphia Phillies, my two English Bulldogs: Odin & Mack, Kayaking and occupying my time designing t-shirts.
Read more

Comments

Guest
Add a comment
0/0

Keywords

Cookie Sandwich Peanut Butter Egg Butter

Similar Recipes

More Recipes

  1. A picture of Kala chana curry with mini Malabar paratha.

    Kala chana curry with mini Malabar paratha

    Pooja Sapre Pooja Sapre
  2. A picture of Picota cherries and grilled steak salad.

    Picota cherries and grilled steak salad

    Picota Cherries Picota Cherries
  3. A picture of Asian spicy cooked egg.

    Asian spicy cooked egg

    Vilde!:) Vilde!:)
  4. A picture of Meringue - 5 Ways simple recipe 1:1:1 - ENJOY :P.

    Meringue - 5 Ways simple recipe 1:1:1 - ENJOY :P

    farang31 farang31
  5. A picture of Cucumber Raita.

    Cucumber Raita

    Nutan Shah Nutan Shah
  6. A picture of Lal Math (Amaranth Leaves) Curry.

    Lal Math (Amaranth Leaves) Curry

    Adv. Vidya D. Umredkar Adv. Vidya D. Umredkar
  7. A picture of Onion and Tomato Tempered Curd Rice.

    Onion and Tomato Tempered Curd Rice

    Manisha Sampat Manisha Sampat
  8. A picture of Blue Cheese and Mushroom Toast.

    Blue Cheese and Mushroom Toast

    Nicky Nicky
  9. A picture of Besan modak.

    Besan modak

    Mukti Sahay Mukti Sahay
  10. A picture of Tasty Dahiwale Alu.

    Tasty Dahiwale Alu

    Prachi Phadke Puranik Prachi Phadke Puranik
  11. A picture of Garlic Butter Chicken & Potatoes.

    Garlic Butter Chicken & Potatoes

    Kristen Pond Kristen Pond
  12. A picture of Broccoli Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo.

    Broccoli Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo

    SouthernHellBelle SouthernHellBelle
  13. A picture of Crawfish cornbread.

    Crawfish cornbread

    codyW codyW
  14. A picture of Teriyaki Salmon (Gluten Free).

    Teriyaki Salmon (Gluten Free)

    Kristen Pond Kristen Pond
  15. A picture of Blueberry Lemon Muffins.

    Blueberry Lemon Muffins

    Christina Christina
  16. A picture of Chocolate Chip Coffee loaf cake (Eggless).

    Chocolate Chip Coffee loaf cake (Eggless)

    PV Iyer PV Iyer
  17. A picture of Double Chocolate Mousse Cake.

    Double Chocolate Mousse Cake

    PV Iyer PV Iyer
  18. A picture of Chocolate Truffles.

    Chocolate Truffles

    PV Iyer PV Iyer
  19. A picture of Kantola ki dry sabji.

    Kantola ki dry sabji

    Mohini Gupta Mohini Gupta
  20. A picture of Gems Chocolate Cake for kids | Atta fruit and nut cake.

    Gems Chocolate Cake for kids | Atta fruit and nut cake

    PV Iyer PV Iyer
  21. A picture of Muffin and egg sandwich.

    Muffin and egg sandwich

    Ashwini Ashwini
  22. A picture of Cabbage & Harusame Salad.

    Cabbage & Harusame Salad

    Hiroko Liston Hiroko Liston
  23. A picture of Vegetarian pilau #pilau contest.

    Vegetarian pilau #pilau contest

    Nyambura Mukururi Nyambura Mukururi
  24. A picture of Sausage stew.

    Sausage stew

    Nyambura Mukururi Nyambura Mukururi
  25. A picture of Mapo Tofu.

    Mapo Tofu

    Dyno Dyno
https://cookpad.wasmer.app/us/recipes/5705426
Cookpad Open in Cookpad App

About Us

Our mission at Cookpad is to make everyday cooking fun, because we believe that cooking is key to a happier and healthier life for people, communities and the planet. We empower home cooks all over the world to help each other by sharing their recipes and cooking experiences.

Subscribe to Premium for exclusive features & benefits!

Cookpad Communities

🇺🇸 United States 🇬🇧 United Kingdom 🇪🇸 España 🇦🇷 Argentina 🇺🇾 Uruguay 🇲🇽 México 🇨🇱 Chile 🇻🇳 Việt Nam 🇹🇭 ไทย 🇮🇩 Indonesia 🇫🇷 France 🇸🇦 السعودية 🇹🇼 臺灣 🇮🇹 Italia 🇮🇷 ایران 🇮🇳 India 🇭🇺 Magyarország 🇳🇬 Nigeria 🇬🇷 Ελλάδα 🇲🇾 Malaysia 🇵🇹 Portugal 🇺🇦 Україна 🇯🇵 日本 See All

Learn More

Cookpad Premium Careers Feedback Blog Terms of Service Community Guidelines Privacy Policy Frequently Asked Questions

Download our app

Open Cookpad App on Google Play Open Cookpad App on App Store
Copyright © Cookpad Inc. All Rights Reserved
close