Homemade Oreo Cookies

The Oreo is a classic American cookie that is perfect for dunking in a cold glass of milk. 🥛 The first Oreos were sold in 1913, and have enjoyed a long period of popularity. I wanted to challenge myself to make a homemade version, and I settled on a recipe by Stella Parks. This recipe doesn’t require black cocoa, but still yields wonderfully crisp wafers that are chocolatey and just a little bitter. 😋
I whipped up a batch to take to a Super Bowl party. Since the hosts of the party were Kansas City Chiefs fans, I colored the filling red and yellow. Sadly, the Chiefs lost, but at least we had these cookies to munch on!
Recipe from Serious Eats
Homemade Oreo Cookies
The Oreo is a classic American cookie that is perfect for dunking in a cold glass of milk. 🥛 The first Oreos were sold in 1913, and have enjoyed a long period of popularity. I wanted to challenge myself to make a homemade version, and I settled on a recipe by Stella Parks. This recipe doesn’t require black cocoa, but still yields wonderfully crisp wafers that are chocolatey and just a little bitter. 😋
I whipped up a batch to take to a Super Bowl party. Since the hosts of the party were Kansas City Chiefs fans, I colored the filling red and yellow. Sadly, the Chiefs lost, but at least we had these cookies to munch on!
Recipe from Serious Eats
Cooking Instructions
- 1
Gather the ingredients. Ensure that the butter is just about room temperature.
- 2
Combine butter, sugar, corn syrup, baking soda, salt, and coconut extract (if using), in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with a paddle attachment.
Mix on low speed to moisten, then increase the speed to medium and beat until fluffy and light (~5 minutes).
You can use a hand mixer if you don’t have a stand mixer. - 3
Whisk the flour and cocoa together in a separate bowl.
- 4
While the stand mixer runs on low, add the flour/cocoa mixture and continue mixing until a stiff dough forms.
- 5
Gather the dough, press into a ball, and divide it in half. Flatten each half into a disc. The stove may be used immediately, or wrapped in plastic and refrigerated for up to 1 week.
- 6
Line cookie sheets with parchment paper.
Preheat your oven to 350°F (177°C). - 7
Generously sprinkle your work surface with cocoa powder, then roll a portion of the dough until it is 1/8 inch (4 mm) thick.
- 8
Use round cookie cutters that are approximately 1 1/2 to 2 inches (3.8 to 5.1 cm) in diameter. Alternatively, you can use fluted cookie cutters or any shape that you want. I used round cutters and stars.
- 9
Cut the desired shapes, and transfer them to the parchment paper-lined cookie sheet. You may need to use an offset spatula to loosen them from your work surface.
Space them about 1/4 inch (6 mm) apart. The cookies will not spread while baking.
Gather the dough scraps, knead, re-roll, and cut again. - 10
Bake the cookies until they are firm and dry. Start checking for doneness after about 11 minutes. Depending on your oven, it may take 13 or 14 minutes total.
Since the dough is very dark colored, you want to err on the side of the cookies being very slightly underbaked. It will be very difficult to tell whether they have burned if you overshoot the cooking time - 11
Cool the cookies completely on the baking sheets.
- 12
Gather the ingredients for the filling.
- 13
This filling cannot be prepared in advance. It will need to be used immediately after preparing it!
In a large pot, melt the butter over medium-low heat, then simmer, stirring constantly with a heat resistant spatula.
- 14
The butter will eventually start hissing and popping. If you notice brown bits forming along the edges, reduce the heat or remove the pot from the heat temporarily.
Continue cooking and stirring until the butter falls silent.
It’s important that you cook off most of the water in the butter. Keep the heat relatively low, and proceed slowly. This step requires patience. - 15
Transfer the butter to the bowl of a stand mixer, fitted with a paddle attachment. Add the vanilla and salt, followed by the sifted powdered sugar.
- 16
Mix on low speed to moisten, then increase to medium. Beat until creamy and soft, about 5 minutes.
- 17
Since I wanted colored filling, I divided the filling in half, and added gel food coloring to each batch.
- 18
Turn half of the wafers upside down in order to prep them for filling.
Each of the cookies will be filled with about a tablespoon of filling. - 19
I think I may have added too much powdered sugar. 😵💫. I was planning on putting the filling into piping bags and filling the cookies that way, but the filling was too thick.
I therefore had to spread the filling onto the wafer cookies with an offset spatula. It was a bit messy, but it got the job done. - 20
The cookies can be stored in an airtight container at room temperature for up to one week, or up to a month in the fridge.
- 21
Once the filling has been added to the bottom wafers, top with the remaining wafers, and join them together with a gentle twist.
Cooksnaps
Did you make this recipe? Share a picture of your creation!
Similar Recipes
-
Oreo Cake Batter Cookies Oreo Cake Batter Cookies
These are absolutely delicious and so easy to make! They are so soft on the inside, even a few days after baking! I'll be making them again soon with some orange dye for Halloween. Kayla Salmon -
Cookies & Cream Oreo Fudge Cookies & Cream Oreo Fudge
Just like the Candy Bar but in a fudge like form. VERY sweet! Very easy to make. angela.walston -
Chocolate chip Oreo cookies cupcakes Chocolate chip Oreo cookies cupcakes
I was asking my husband one day if you were a cupcake what flavor would you be and he said I don't know and as I was getting ready for bed I thought of these Macintosh -
My Oreo cookie frosting My Oreo cookie frosting
I was making a cake for my son's birthday and it was a big hit Macintosh -
Oreo cookie lasagna Oreo cookie lasagna
Absolutely amazing, i would recommend maybe adding some graham cracker crumbs to the bottom crust bryna.johnstone -
Oreo Brownies with Cookie Dough Frosting Oreo Brownies with Cookie Dough Frosting
I love brownies and Oreos so I thought why not put the two together! Adrienne -
Cookies n' Cream Oreo Fudge Brownies Cookies n' Cream Oreo Fudge Brownies
This was another experiment with overwhelming results! HardDog1110 -
Authentic Oreo Cookies & Cream Ice Cream Authentic Oreo Cookies & Cream Ice Cream
I make ice cream almost every day during the summer, and even in winter I make it about twice a week.I've used many recipes as the based and adapted them.If you crush the Oreos in a plastic bag and mix them in from the start to the ice cream mix, the crumbs will make the ice cream look dirty.Break up the Oreo cookies so they don't turn into crumbs. Mix them in halfway through the churning process for a nice finish.The ice cream has to be rested however, or the cookie bits won't be softened enough.If you add the Oreo cookies at the start, the ice cream won't look as nice, but it will taste great. For 3 to 4 servings. Recipe by Yuichinmama cookpad.japan -
Vickys Oreo Cookies, GF DF EF SF NF Vickys Oreo Cookies, GF DF EF SF NF
My kids love Oreos but we can't buy them gluten or soy-free over here - so we make them ourselves instead! Vicky@Jacks Free-From Cookbook -
Oreo cookie cheesecake Oreo cookie cheesecake
The kids love cheesecake & oreo cookies so I combined the two. success.. 416sandra -
Chuck Full Of Oreo Sugar Cookies Chuck Full Of Oreo Sugar Cookies
these cookies are soo good that everyone will want some! great christmas gifts! renee
More Recipes
Comments (5)